|
Federal Republic of Yugoslavia
Economic Reform Program for 2001
Miroljub Labus,
Federal Deputy Prime Minister
Belgrade, December
9th, 2000
This paper presents
the economic reform program for 2001 of the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia (hereinafter "FRY"), as well as broad lines of
our mid-term program (2002-2005). Internally, its objective is to
serve as a firm guide for the formulation of specific economic
measures. Externally, its goal is to serve as an important element
in the dialogue between the FRY and the international community, in
particular the European Union, G8 and other countries, and
international financial institutions, directly or within the
framework set by the Stability Pact for South-Eastern Europe.
After a brief
background, the program presents chronologically the four main
phases of economic reform:
-
"Enforcing
stability and preparing reform", covering measures
to be implemented until the end of 2000 ;
-
"First
100 days for a normal life", covering the first quarter
of 2001 ;
-
"Stabilizing
the economy and rekindling growth", covering the
remaining three quarters of 2001 ;
-
Finally, main
elements of the mid-term program covering the period 2002-2005 "Driving
towards a prosperous society and European Union
membership".
Background
After more than ten
years of dramatic economic decline, economic sanctions, severe
regional instability, mismanagement and corruption, the FRY is
embarking on a radical economic reform path with ambitious goals. We
want to catch up rapidly with other Central European economies, be
part of the international economy and join the European Union as a
full member in about five to seven years. Our strategic mid-term
goals are to create an efficient open market economy, to eradicate
corruption, to protect the neediest and to increase sharply living
standards. We believe that many characteristics of our economy
before the 90s crisis: longstanding economic links with Western and
other markets, a tradition of entrepreneurship and autonomous
enterprise management, the economic potential of the Diaspora, etc.,
should allow us to reach those goals under responsible economic
management.
We are preparing a
comprehensive economic package covering five years (2001-2005), to
be started in earnest at the beginning of 2001 after the
installation of the new Serbian government following the December 23rd
elections. Its main elements will be ready for the new Serbian
cabinet. The Federal government will then collaborate closely with
the new Serbian government and work in harmony with the Montenegrin
government to implement such a program.
An economy in ruins
However, these
ambitious yet achievable goals contrast starkly with the current
difficult economic realities. The population experiences cuts in
electricity and heating delivery, as well as basic staple shortages
(cooking oil, sugar). Pensions and salaries are paid with
considerable delays. Around 35% of the population are officially or
effectively unemployed, 30% live below or close to the regional
poverty line, and around 800,000 refugees and internally displaced
persons lack basic necessities. Overall, people have to cope with
steep food price increases, very low salaries by regional standards.
Savings are very low and many segments of the society have run out
of reserves. Any further shock to the standard of living would be
devastating for them. The infrastructure is suffering from many
years of decay, mismanagement and the consequences of the NATO 1999
bombing campaign. Inflation will reach over 70% on an annual basis.
After being swindled several times by state and private banks in the
90s, the population has lost trust in the banking sector and the
level of monetization is exceptionally low at 3-4% of GDP. Real
fiscal revenues and expenditures are much lower than planned because
of tax exemptions, rate cuts and the development of the grey
economy. The consolidated budget deficit will reach in 2000 at least
8 to 10% of GDP when non-financial arrears are taken into account.
Bad debts and inter enterprise arrears are a permanent threat to
macro stability as they represent, according to available estimates,
around 80% of the GDP. Finally, despite its willingness to honor
again its international debts, the country is not in a position to
do so, as the level of debt represents approximately 140% of the
GDP.
In sum, the FRY is
facing both transition and post-conflict problems. After leading the
transition process at the beginning of the decade, the country is
now lagging behind the most advanced transition economies. Its
reform path has to recognize this peculiarity and be very dynamic
and ambitious. This is also why the country will require significant
external support, in the form of humanitarian assistance but also
technical assistance, training, budgetary support, grants and loans.
International support
for reform: helping us to break with the past
We will mobilize all
our internal resources to overcome this dire starting position and
reform rapidly. The FRY certainly does not want to become dependent
on foreign assistance. We want to be a self-sustaining country,
benefiting mostly from foreign private investment flows and
international trade. We recognize the need to restructure deeply our
economy. However, given the enormous weight of the past, we will
require significant backing from the international community in the
short term to succeed, in particular from the European Union, other
governments, and international financial organizations such as the
IMF, the World Bank, the EBRD, the OECD and others. This backing
would be squarely aimed at "breaking with the past" by
relieving the country from the effects of accumulated arrears and
debts, so as to be able to focus above all on building a new,
democratic and prosperous, Yugoslavia.
We expect that our
program will attract significant support from the international
community. We have benefited from the start of the democratic
transformation from a quick mobilization of the international
community on gas, food and electricity needs, and a few countries
have also provided some budgetary support. We are extremely grateful
for this help. Negotiations of a post-conflict emergency program of
the IMF for the first quarter of 2001 are well under way. Agreement
on this program is encapsulated in our "Statement of Economic
Policies" whose economic policy measures for the first quarter
of 2001 are simply restated here. We hope to conclude negotiations
during the first quarter of 2001 on a one-year stand by arrangement
with the IMF. In addition, as our arrears so great, breaking up with
the past will be close to impossible won our own. This is why we
hope to engage discussions with donors countries and European Union
on budgetary support so as to cover part of these arrears, enabling
us to focus on the present and future. Finally, later in 2001 we
expect to negotiate of a three-year EFF program with the IMF and to
agree on a Stabilization and Association Agreement with the European
Union.
In order to start
addressing this difficult situation while putting the country on the
path of economic development, the FRY will implement until the end
of the year 2005 a program in the above mentioned four phases. This
document focuses on the measures to be implemented until the end of
the year 2001.
First phase: "Enforcing stability and preparing reform"
(until the end of the year 2000)
Over the coming month
the government will implement measures to ease shortages, provide
support to the neediest while maintaining under control the economy.
The needs will be financed from domestic sources and foreign
contributions, both in kind and financial. Economic measures are
grouped under the following ten areas (see attachment for an
overview of individual measures):
-
Monetary policy
and exchange rate policy .
Monetary policy will remain restrictive, as has been the case
since the latest political changes. This has helped in reducing
the market rate level, which has been kept at 30 dinars for a
DEM for the past several weeks. The foreign exchange rates were
unified on December 6th to its market level and the
exchange rate will be maintained within a 5% band of the market
rate following this unification. By January 1st 2001,
the dinar will become convertible on current account
transactions. This key reform will be accompanied by the
introduction of new dinar denominations. The NBY will avoid
giving credits to the budget or enterprises. However, rapid
price liberalization by the outgoing Serbian government has
provoked very high inflation in October (26%) and November
(18%). We will attempt to keep this rate below 10% in December.
-
Fiscal policy,
wage policy, price policy.
The budgetary situation is extremely difficult because of a poor
execution of the 2000 budget at all levels: federal, republican,
local and within social funds. In aggregate it is estimated that
the consolidated cash budget deficit will be about 0.5% of the
GDP, but accumulated arrears will reach at least 8-10%
(pensions, child allowances, etc.). The Serbian government has
already passed a set of measures to increase revenues, including
hikes in excise levels and better enforcement of customs rules,
which will be partly offset by a 30% wage increase for civil
servants.
-
Foreign trade
regime . The federal
government is preparing a significant reform of the foreign
trade regime with a view of suppressing excessive administrative
regulations, revising import and export licenses, limiting the
use of quotas and reducing excessive tariff levels. Several
specific measures need to be undertaken to provide further
competition in certain sectors, in particular in durable goods.
-
Inter-enterprise
arrears, bad debts . A
full picture of accumulated debts between enterprises and
between enterprises and banks will be provided at the end of the
year and a systematic approach will be prepared for discussion
with the World Bank.
-
Social policy and
labor policy . In addition
to organizing auctions for "in kind" donations and
integrating direct budgetary support of various governments and
the EU, the Serbian government is preparing a social safety net
program for implementation during 2001.
-
European
integration . We are
currently analyzing the elements of the ‘acquis communautaire’
and want to insure their inclusion in the overall reform
package.
-
Banking reform,
capital markets . A quick
audit of all major banks has already been launched with the help
of an international audit firm and will be ready by the end of
the year. It will be followed by an in depth analysis of the
banking sector which will yield an objective ranking of the
banks, and some will receive a limited deposit guarantee to
revive savings.
-
Infrastructure .
Numerous projects are being discussed with the EIB and several
other ones are under consideration with private sector actors.
-
Privatization .
The Serbian privatization law is being reviewed so as to either
amend the existing law or prepare a new one. The goal will be to
speed up privatization and make the process more open and
transparent, taking into account the rich lessons of experience
of other transition countries.
-
External debt .
The federal government is gathering data and initiating contacts
with international creditors.
Second phase:
"First 100 days for a normal life" (first quarter of 2001)
Following the
elections for the Serbian Parliament on December 23rd and
the subsequent appointment of the Serbian government, the Federal
and the Republican Governments will launch a dynamic 100 day
(January/March) program: «100 days for a normal life». We expect
this program to be supported by an IMF first drawing. As mentioned,
we also expect to finalize negotiations during this period for an
IMF stand by arrangement and a budgetary support and macro finance
program negotiated with key donors. Economic measures will include
the following ones:
-
Monetary policy
and exchange rate policy .
The dinar will continue to be managed under a floating regime.
We expect the exchange rate to remain fairly stable given our
tight credit policy, which will entail keeping the net domestic
assets of the NBY stable. Real interest rates will be maintained
at positive levels. The goal will be to let the market find the
appropriate equilibrium exchange rate. IMF agreement on a floor
on net foreign assets and ceiling on net domestic asset will be
respected. The target inflation levels will be 2 to 5% per
month. Financial transactions between Serbia and Montenegro will
be based on a market mechanism between two convertible monies.
-
Fiscal policy,
wage policy, price policy .
A cash based three month consolidated temporary budget will be
computed and its execution will be closely monitored at all
levels (federal, republican, local, social funds). Any deficit
will be financed through real sources, with the exception of a
possible seasonal 500 million dinar borrowing by the Serbian
budget. A gradual liberalization of the few remaining controlled
prices will start (electricity).
-
Foreign trade
regime . A comprehensive
reform bringing the regime closer to European norms will be
implemented with the help of Western technical assistance.
-
Inter-enterprise
arrears, bad debts . An
overall approach to solving this problem, coordinated with the
banking reform, will be proposed with the support of technical
assistance from the World Bank and other financial institutions.
-
Social policy,
labor policy, education policy, health policy .
Social policy measures will be increasingly directed towards the
neediest and a comprehensive social safety net program will be
implemented. No new indexation measures will be introduced. We
will need to revise our education and health policies.
-
European
integration . We will
provide the European Union with an overall description of
economic policies as, we hope, a basis for a negotiated
macrofinance loan and budgetary support negotiation during this
quarter. A platform for a multi-year approach towards the EU
will be implemented. All regulations will start being harmonized
with the « acquis communautaire».
-
Banking reform,
capital markets . We will
study the possibility of letting several high quality foreign
banks will to enter the market. In addition, regulations will
start being harmonized with the European ones. We will also
start giving back hard currency from frozen accounts to citizens
according to the appropriate law. This is a key measure to boost
confidence in the banking sector.
-
Infrastructure .
First projects with the EIB and private companies should start
and further tenders will be organized.
-
Privatization .
On the basis of amendments to the Serbian Law, a tight timetable
will be given for the completion of the privatization program. A
few sales will be sought, where interest on several foreign
investors is manifest and open tender can be organized. In order
to boost the profile of the country in international markets, a
specialized agency for foreign direct investments will be
created.
-
External
assistance and debt . The
Federal government will seek a meeting of the Consultative group
of all creditors in March/April 2001. We will propose a program
of rescheduling/relief. Given the situation of the country, and
in the spirit of getting a chance for a new start, we expect a
significant debt relief.
Third phase: "Stabilizing the economy and rekindling
growth" (April-December 2001)
Toward the end of the
first quarter of 2001, with the support from the EU, other
governments and the IMF, as well as expected positive effects of
earlier economic policy measures the country will launch a full
blown economic reform package supported by deep structural reforms.
-
Monetary policy
and exchange rate policy .
After finding an equilibrium level for the exchange rate,
several options will be considered for the regime. The goal will
be to maintain competitiveness of the economy. Target monthly
inflation will not exceed 2%. The NBY will move to indirect
monetary policy tools.
-
Fiscal policy,
wage policy, price policy .
A consolidated, revenue-driven, revised budget for 2001 will be
voted on the Serbian level. All extra budgetary lines will be
consolidated within the overall budget in order to provide badly
needed transparency. Its target deficit will be limited and we
will seek to finance it through external grants. No soft loans
will be provided to enterprises, directly or through the banking
system. Overall, we expect to reduce the overall fiscal burden
by several points of the GDP. While executing the 2001 budget, a
comprehensive, EU compatible, fiscal reform will be
progressively implemented and used as the basis for the 2002
budget. We will seek to base core expenditures on stable
revenues which we will work hard to collect, so as to avoid
further arrears. Strict procurement rules will be implemented.
In order to boost public trust in the State, improve quality of
fiscal services and increase fiscal transparency, an independent
institution will be created. Its role will be to control the
effective execution of the expenditures of the budget and rate
services, which are provided to the public. By the end of the
year, energy prices will be brought closer to world levels.
-
Foreign trade
regime . We will start
negotiations will the EU and the WTO, and establish free trade
agreements with as many of the neighboring countries as
possible.
-
Inter-enterprise
arrears, bad debts . We
will seek a clean cut from the past, and an orderly resolution
of the problem, so as to avoid old debts influencing the
behavior of economic agents going forward while avoid moral
hazard issues. Five to six banks will work with Western banks
and/or the EBRD to implement internationally accepted prudential
methods and create workout departments.
-
Social policy and
labor policy . We will
continue to better target a social safety net program and
increase the flexibility of the job market.
-
European
integration . We will
start negotiations with the EU on a SAA agreement, and start
negotiations on an accession platform.
-
Banking reform,
capital markets . We will
seek to privatize several large banks, either through a direct
sale to foreign investors or through stock market floatation.
-
Infrastructure .
We will start a host of projects with the EIB and other
institutions. We will conduct an international tender for a
third GSM license.
-
Privatization .
An all-encompassing program, with attached timetables and
quantitative goals will use several models: case by case, mass
privatization, liquidation, and other methods. We recognize that
different companies will require different approaches. We also
believe that this will be the best approach to satisfy the
several goals of a privatization program: raising revenues,
improving corporate governance. We will seek early successes
through significant operations early on and ensure transparency
in the process. We will do our outmost to prevent corruption in
this process.
-
External debt .
Full-fledged renegotiations should provide for orderly
repayments and the preparation of the return of the FRY to
international capital markets.
Fourth phase: Driving towards a
prosperous society and European Union membership (2002-2005)
A strong team of
Yugoslav experts including Federal Government and Republican
government representatives is currently drafting the mid-term
package of economic reform. It should be ready by the end of January
2001, in time for its immediate implementation by the new Serbian
government. This preparation benefits from the support of local and
international experts, and technical assistance from international
financial organizations and foreign governments.
The main elements of
this mid term program stem from our twin strategic goals: to join
the European Union and to integrate into the international economy.
The main elements are the following:
- Monetary and fiscal strategy to
insure sustainable macro economic stability and Euro
requirements;
- Deep reform of public finances and
tax policy;
- Liberalization of all prices;
- Flexibility of the labor market;
- Implementation of a new pension
scheme;
- Anti monopoly reform;
- Completion of the privatization
program;
- Creation of an equity capital
market;
- Liberalization of the capital
account;
* * *
In closing, we
believe that the proposed program will allow Yugoslavia to progress
rapidly on the economic development path. However, strong support
from the international community, including budgetary support, macro
finance support and debt relief, is, we believe, a pre-condition for
success. We will do our outmost to reform our country want to be
judged on our performance. We do not want our country to become a
regular recipient of international support. But the weight of the
last thirteen years is simply too big for a country of our strength.
We hope that the international community well recognize this fact
and act accordingly. On our side, we will remain committed to a
committed, open and corruption free reform process. It is, we
believe, what we must offer to our people, after so many years of
instability, isolation and pauperization.
Attachment: Synthetic view of planned
economic policy measures until the end of year 2001
(pdf, 20 KB)
|